Our story

McGregor Pizza Company is locally-owned and operated!

McGregor Pizza Company

McGregor Pizza Company formally McGregor Pizza and Deli is locally owned and operated by Katie Madden Marciano, a Fort Myers native who grew up in the Historic McGregor Boulevard in Downtown Fort Myers. As a child, Katie loved riding her bike to what was once called, “Little Farm Market” for some candy and has always dreamed of owning her own little spot off McGregor. Dreams do come true, and Katie opened McGregor Pizza Company in 2017. In 2022 the dream continued, and Katie opened a 2nd location in San Carlos Park

In addition to Florida, Katie has also lived in the U.S. Virgin Islands, New York and Israel and has been working in the food and beverage industry for most of her adult life. McGregor Pizza Company is a neighborhood-friendly environment with indoor and outdoor dining and offers takeout and delivery.

Stop in to see Katie and have a slice!

2020 Winner of 99.3 ESPN’s The Slice Is Right SWFL’s Best Pizza Challenge

#1 in the Top 5 Best Pizza Places in SWFL

Check out our full bio in the News Press and review by Jean Le Boeuf

See The Dish: Highlights from Local Menus at Florida Weekely reviewed by Laura Tichy

“Not only is the pizza fantastic but their revised service due to COVID-19 has put any anxiety about outside food at ease. Thank you McGregor Pizza, we love your food and fantastic service!!“


Jenna A.

“We had a particularly delicious pizza from Mcgregor Pizza tonight. It’s often difficult to find NY style thin pizza that is cooked crisp enough to hold properly but this pizzeria does it well. Keep up the good work, we will be back for sure.


Bitsy S.

“We’re proud Chicago area natives and its hard to impress us with pizza, but McGregor Pizza and Deli nailed it! Best pizza in the area!“


Phil V

“The pizza here is awesome. Fresh salads. Good wine. Friendly service. Fast delivery. Great location!“


Sandy S.

“Great place for pizza lovers, also the rest of the food is fantastic. The service and the place is 5 stars. Very recommended for small or big family.“


Yoan R


McGregor Blvd
(239) 939-1148

4600 McGregor Blvd
Fort Myers,
FL 33901

San Carlos Park
(239) 400-0965

18011 S Tamiami Trail #13
Fort Myers,
FL 33908


Tue-Thu: 11 am – 9 pm
Fri-Sat: 11 am – 9:30 pm
Sun: 12 pm – 8 pm
Closed Mondays